I’ve always said that “perfection” is accidental. It is my experience in life that the things we tend to try and “perfect” from the get go usually end up falling flat in one form or another because you’ve set your expectations and the bar so high right from the start.
My interpretation of perfection in chips usually pertains to 60s era TRKs mostly from Reno Nevada Casinos. What makes these chips so sought after IMO is a combination of many things for different collectors.
As you mentioned “inconsistent fonts and hand crafted work.” As
@Blackbeard mentions the secrecy behind the lead and clay formulas and not quite being able to clone it exactly in todays time.
For me, my love of 60s Reno TRKs is a combination of things. Look at it this way, you only fall in love for the first time once. 60s Reno TRKs are accidental perfection from a golden era in chipping and Americana for that matter.
I’ve always enjoyed mob type movies and many of the casinos from that era had lots of shady type owners and operators. The stories of Lincoln Fitzgerald and Pick Hobson are fascinating to me and remind me of people like my grandmother. This is a picture of her chipping concrete from the Berlin Wall in 1990. It hangs currently in my card room.
View attachment 206
Learning to play cards was mostly taught to me by my grandmother. She was born in the 1930s and in the late 1970s and early 80s when she started teaching me 5 card draw, 5 and 7 card stud, 31 which she called “Cad” and Tripoli, I got excited at the opportunity to win a couple bucks trying to outsmart her and others we may play with at back in those times. As a young boy it felt good to be included in the degeneracy so to speak.
I got to listen to all the stories of my grandmother’s experiences in that “golden era” of Americana that was the same times as when many of these chips were produced.
I fell into collecting chips completely by accident. I’ve always considered myself a “player” first and a “collector” second. My first set of what I consider nice casino type chips was World Top Hat and Cane chips.
It was the color of the $1 chip that originally did it for me, not being a typical white colored $1 chip like in most sets or casinos I’d play in or with.
Putting together my WTHCs, stumbling briefly onto “chip talk” and then that other place, getting a couple barrels of Pick Hobson $25s and eventually a few racks of PH $5s, led me to the discovery of what in my eyes was perfection in a poker chip.
The Nevada Lodge $25. This one chip says “Perfect” to all my poker chip scenes.
View attachment 204
For me it is this chip that led me on an almost 7 year quest to complete a rack and playable set. And it is this completed set that brings all of my poker experiences and appreciations for what I’ve learned, experienced and discovered in chipping, poker and life for that matter, together.
View attachment 205
Working on this set gave me a much greater sense of what perfection for me, actually is.
My guess would be that Leonardo Da Vinci probably thought his painting of Mona Lisa was just another painting at the time.
True perfection isn’t something created but rather it is something “Discovered” IMO.